The only problem I see, is that they are an easy target for a modern army.
There needs to be a balance. Going full /cyb/tard is not working out that well. But you are not beating globo-homo's mech-army, armed only with strong family values and a stable fertility rate.
>>365155>But you are not beating globo-homo's mech-army, armed only with strong family values and a stable fertility rate.Sure, the Amish lack kinetic power but they are impervious to demoralization.
>>365157Yes, undermining the Amish through subversion would be extremely hard. That's why am only really concerned about direct physical confrontation.
A much more "industrial" society is better suited for that. But then, all the other problems come back.
I know natsoc Germany was a thing. But times have changed.
I just wonder how a "balanced" model, suited for today's circumstances would look like. Regardless, it would definitely consider the Amish lifestyle.
>>365163>That's why am only really concerned about direct physical confrontation.Well, until now globohomo left them alone, perhaps they are not perceived as a threat, yet. But I'm sure they will come after them with regulations and laws to make them submit. If there is a people the jews hate more, Christians fit the profile.
>Regardless, it would definitely consider the Amish lifestyle.This.
The Amish, Mormons and Mexicans will fight a three-way civil war at some point in the future.
>>365155>But you are not beating globo-homo's mech-army, armed only with strong family values and a stable fertility rate.Fair enough. But I personally believe that true faith in God can grant you victory by His hand that goes against all odds. I think the Amish are already a living miracle simply by still existing right in the heart of the JewSA.
>>365552>But I personally believe that true faith in God can grant you victory by His hand that goes against all odds.I agree. But I also think >we shouldn't fall into inaction because of this. Pray for the Lord's aid, but try your hardest to overcome the obstacle regardless. The best of your efforts, not just spiritually, but physically and mentally.
You need land to live like that Amish, and a lot of it. I can't afford to live the way they do.
>>366182Yes, and you need your society to be nested within another society, or you'll just be decimated in war.
>>366228Also true, but how is that relevant to the other point?
>>366228Think about the Amish like the control group who didn't take the cultural marxist pill. Their very presence is a reminder of what America could be.
>or you'll just be decimated in warThis is very unlikely as America is actually shielded by oceans and has no hostile neighbors. Also its huge land mass make it almost impossible to take over. The prospect of military invasion is a myth and not based on reality.
>>366231>Also its huge land mass make it almost impossible to take over.This is only assuming there's a certain level of resistance. Grassroots americans involved in guerrilla warfare would be enough. But the amish don't even have that.
>The prospect of military invasion is a myth and not based on reality.Because america has an actual standing army. A large material arsenal and lots of armed civilians that could use the huge countryside to their advantage.
If the entire country was amish. They would need to make some compromises to be able to defend themselves.
>>365152I do believe in the Amish model.
>>366524I do believe indeed.
And the best he and his pals can do is to surrender their jets and yachts together with their armored cars and energy-hog mansions.
>>366229They're a protected group that has zero external hardpoints, limited resources, poor economic efficiency, and massive amounts of inbreeding. Without Big Brother they wouldn't last more than a few weeks.
>>366231>has no hostile neighbors>no hostile neighbors>no>hostile>neighborsDouble check that again.
Carefully. >>366559>Without Big Brother they wouldn't last more than a few weeks.What do they get from the government?
>>366562Cops, unironically. The Amish can't even handle the occasional lone nigger by themselves.
Don't get me wrong, they are cool and all. But if they were specifically targeted in any way. It would pretty much be curtains.
>>366564>The Amish can't even handle the occasional lone nigger by themselves.What makes you say they can't handle a love nigger?
They love in areas where niggers are scarce. Cops don't patrol that often near Amish communities, so they're not anymore reliant on them than other Americans.
I'm not idolizing them in like some others in this thread, but I don't believe that they're in any way overly dependent on the government.
>>366565>love niggerEw
>What makes you say they can't handle a *lone nigger?Because they literally can't. Despite the fact encounters are pretty rare. They've never successfully defended themselves. Imagine if they were actually targeted.
>>366567>They've never successfully defended themselves.How many times have they actually been targeted?
>>366568That's the point. Any concerted effort would break them. Thus far, a single uppity nigger has been too much to handle.
>>366569That doesn't sound very evidence-based.
>Thus far, a single uppity nigger has been too much to handleWhen did this happen?
>>366571So you're telling me you made it up? Great. Really convincing.
There is zero evidence to suggest that these people are less equipped to deal with hostile niggers wandering into their land than any other American community.
>>366575Give me a single reason why I should believe you.
I'm certain that the Amish would easily be killed off if armed people organized to exterminate them, being just a bunch of farmers, but this weird claim that they're defenseless in the face of random lone niggers is preposterous.
>>366576>why I should believe youI'm a different anon. Do not believe please.
>>366574>>366576>So you're telling me you made it up?Not really, I simply wasn't sure if you were serious or just trolling. Because this should be plenty easy to grasp.
>There is zero evidence to suggest that these people are less equipped to deal with hostile niggers wandering into their land than any other American community.I guess there lies our misunderstanding. Amish people are killed off all the time by niggers. This is easily verifiable with a simple google search. It is also plenty easy to verify that no Amish has ever successfully engaged in self-defense.
I guess you could argue no nigger has yet decided to storm one of their villages in the middle of no where. But, does it even matter? When the Amish haven't successfully defended themselves against niggers, or anybody for that matter, at all, ever?
>>366580I don't know what really is happening in PA and surroundings but there is a chance that niggers might not be able to leave the area alive. No government shooters are needed.
>>366581Not in the loop tbh. But I wish good luck to whomever is shooting the niggers in any case. And if they shoot the zogbots too, even better.
I guess what am trying to say is that the Amish need to adapt if they are to succeed as a model. Which I don't consider to be so unlikely. I've heard some of them have pretty decent hunting rifles, and even cameras to aid in their hunting. That's a good start.
>>366582>I've heard some of them have pretty decent hunting riflesThat's what I was thinking of.
And taking in count that zogbots are liberals (freemasons) and therefore anti-White and anti-Christian to the core, better the Amish stay away from them.
>>366564Not just badge niggers: the same
infrastructure they decry as (((eViL))). They aren't self sufficient when they require outside resources that cannot be produced, especially metals.