This is a discussion thread, not a planning thread for a piece of media that would actually try to accomplish this in some way(Too busy right now to even consider doing that), so how would you personally write this and go about doing this? What pros and cons are there to the different methods available, and what would you prefer to see?
Personally I think Them's Fighting Herds went too far with its changes. You can still tell who each pony is supposed to be, but some of the most important ponies have had their personalities changed too much for the group dynamic to be the same. I reckon a more "This is quite clearly The Mane Six but shapeshifted into different-looking bodies" approach would work better for this.
If were going to make some kind of spiritual successor to MLP:FIM, I wouldn't think the personalities ought to be carbon copies of the mane six. The personalities of the mane six worked really well for furthering the ideals the show promoted (at least in S1 and S2,) and complimented each other's personalities with their different eccentricities, but I believe an original work is generally much more memorable than an imitation, and allows more room for exploring new dynamics, and new ways of putting forth the values that the series originally stood for.
I think if we're ever going to do a "fan continuation of MLP", it would be best to do it as a webcomic released not in weekly installments but in Full-Chapter Story Arcs.
It's like waiting for Pony Fridays. Except you're waiting weeks for a bulk upload of 24ish comic pages in which a story is told.
Now this would be fucking easy because pony vector art is fucking easy.
It's just fucking tracing in Ponyscape. It's like the vector art used by Ctrl Alt Delete only good.
Anyway, this system ensures you won't get copystriked by Hasbro in the middle of a story arc.
Then again for a more viable long term solution an "original" setting with "original" characters would be much better. Kind of like Them's Fighting Herds only vital characters don't lose what made them special in the process.
>>249222That sounds interesting, what original characters did you have in mind?